With
his latest move to change one of Orthodox Christianity’s most powerful symbols
from a museum into a mosque Turkey’s President Tayyip Erdoğan is once again
demonstrating his complete contempt for international cooperation or opinion.
He simply doesn’t care – at all. The only thing important to him is to maintain
the unwavering support of his nationalist and fundamentalist Islamic base of
support, a base that has shown signs of weakening in recent years.
Haghia Sophia before the Ottoman conquest |
To the world at large Erdoğan is Turkey.
That is a serious mistake. His main damage over the years has been to obscure
the complex, rich reality of Turkey – a complexity which he loathes. There are
literally millions of hard working, well educated people in Turkey who reject his
narrow, inward view of the world. They want to engage with the rest of the world not retreat from it. Indeed in the
last round of municipal elections they showed their strength when the opposition
won almost all the major cities including Istanbul. These cities and
surrounding areas contain the bulk of
Turkey’s population and the vast majority of the country’s economic activity. There
are promising signs that the success in local elections could be carried to the
national level. This is what Erdoğan really fears and why he has to work hard
to maintain is base of support.
Why is the status of Haghia Sophia
so important? Constructed in the 6th century AD by Byzantine Emperor
Justinian it stood for almost 1,000 years as a powerful symbol of Christianity
with its soaring dome and glittering mosaics. When the Ottoman Turks conquered
Constantinople in 1453 one of their first acts was to convert this symbol into
a mosque. It remained a mosque until 1934 when the Turkish republic’s first
president Kemal Ataturk – determined to secularize and modernize the country –
converted it into a museum. Thus it remained until today. Erdoğan and his
fervent followers deeply resent Ataturk’s secularization drive and have tried
over the years to weaken his hold on the Turkish public. The conversion of
Haghia Sophia back into a mosque is simply their latest, boldest, step in
trying to settle decades-old grievances against Ataturk’s legacy and the outside
world – especially the perfidious West. It remains to be seen if their Islamic
zeal will make them destroy the remnants of the original glorious 6th
century mosaics inside Haghia Sophia. After all, human representation in any
artistic form is an anathema for Islamic fundamentalists.
Will these precious mosaics in Haghia Sophia be destroyed? |
Is there anything the rest of the
world can do to make Erdoğan reverse this decision? In the short term, not
really. Isolated in his bubble and surrounded by sycophants he is impervious to
criticism – especially from Europe. This time is slightly different in that
Orthodox Russia has also severely criticized the conversion. But the Russian
condemnation quickly gets tangled in the delicate and complex web of
Russian/Turkish relations and might not have much effect.
But that doesn’t mean other
countries and international organizations are completely impotent in this
matter. Erdoğan is a very shrewd, clever villager who has little knowledge of
or interest in the rest of the world. But up to now has played his
international counterparts like a harp. They can flap their arms in despair at
some of Erdoğan’s moves, express all the righteous indignation they want and he
just laughs because he knows full well those are empty gestures. They won’t do
anything. Turkey may be resource poor but it occupies what has been considered
a critical piece of geography, literally spanning East and West. It is a member
of NATO and played a key role during the Cold War. However, those ties are
fraying and Turkey’s useful role is being questioned more and more. There are also
strong elements in Turkey that want to get rid of all Western alliances and
focus more on Eurasia – an area they feel is more politically and socially
compatible with their 16th century vision for Turkey. Much of Turkey’s economic elite is
horrified at such an Iranization of the country, but it’s not clear how much –
if any – influence this elite has.
Erdogan in a familiar pose |
Erdoğan loves to stress that Turkey
is a sovereign nation and can make its own decisions. True enough. But other
nations are also sovereign and are perfectly free to make their own reactions
to Erdoğan’s moves. Merely whining does no good at all. He feeds on that. It is
time to get serious and call his bluff. He wants to change the status of
historic monuments? Fine. But there must be consequences, regardless of any
inconvenience. International cultural organizations could make Erdoğan’s Turkey
a pariah and withdraw the country’s membership. Yes, there are countless
valuable antiquities in Turkey. But if anyone thinks coddling Erdoğan is the
way to preserve those he is kidding himself. He has shown an undying love of
modern concrete over natural beauty or ancient sites – especially if they are
Christian.
What else could be done? Erdoğan is
exposed in Syria. Yes, the Assad regime is an abomination but Orthodox
Christians in Syria should be very afraid of the alternative of the fundamental
Sunnis, the Al Qaeda offshoots supported by Erdoğan. The West together with
Russia could put serious pressure on Assad to do a deal with the Kurds, who
hate Erdoğan, and work for a loose federation that keeps Syria together while
getting rid of the Turkish occupation of the north-western part of the country.
Thanks to Erdoğan’s mismanagement
the country’s economy has become quite fragile with an over-reliance on
imports, dwindling foreign currency reserves, high unemployment and massive foreign
currency debt obligations. Officials may be adept at managing these challenges
in the short term but longer term the country will pay a high price.
Ah, but the immigrants you say.
Annoy him too much and he can unleash millions of immigrants – most of whom are
not Syrian refugees -- into Europe. Yes and no. Several months ago Greece
showed what could be done with a little resolve. Close the border. Bulgaria
could do the same. Most civilized countries recoil at such measures. But it is
up to Europe to set its own immigration terms and not permit Erdoğan to use
these unfortunates as pawns to intimidate other countries.